*An artist’s impression of the Ennis Data Centre. 

THE HIGH Court has ruled that a report error concerning a bat located in a barn outside Ennis is not sufficient to halt contentious plans for a new 200MW €1.2bn data centre campus.

This follows Mr Justice Richard Humphreys dismissing objectors’ claims that an An Bord Pleanála inspector’s error concerning a bat roost containing a single Leisler’s Bat, who was a resident in March 2022, in a crack in the external wall of a barn shed in farmland near Ennis, Co. Clare should stop the Ennis data centre campus

In the first line of his 28 page judgement, Mr Justice Humphreys commented, “The Bat in Building 6C could be an episode title in a Scandi Noir series. But it describes our subject here”.

Dismissing the objectors’ grounds over the Leisler Bat, Mr Justice Humphreys described the inspector’s error about the bat on page 74 of the inspector’s report as ‘harmless’.

He said, “A decision should not be quashed for error (including in application of EU law) if the error was harmless and did not materially affect the result”.

An Bord Pleanála granted planning permission for the scheme in April 2024 comprising six data halls covering 145 acres or 1.3m sq ft on lands adjacent to the Tulla Rd on the eastern outskirts of Ennis near Junction 13 on the M18 motorway connecting Galway to Limerick.

However, opponents of the data centre, Colin Doyle, Friends of the Irish Environment CLG, Futureproof Clare, Martin Knox and Christine Sharp sought a High Court judicial review of the appeals board permission.

In October, An Bord Pleanála conceded the objectors’ claim for quashing the board’s data centre planning permission where they admitted that the Board erred in law in failing to consider adequately the environmental effects of the proposed development on bat fauna.

However, applicants for the centre, Art Data Centres Ltd contested the appeals board’s High Court judicial review concession to the objectors.

Now in his ruling after a one day hearing in the High Court, Mr Justice Humphreys has stated that the case dismissal “is a modest piece of recent legal history in that no previous developer in the State has succeeded in demonstrating as misconceived an objection that the appeals board was prepared to concede”.

He said, “For a certain type of observer, the fate of a single roost containing a single bat will be viewed as a trivial basis for a debate about the validity of the planning permission. That is perhaps understandable at a superficial level but is a misconception”.

He remarks, “Obviously the issue isn’t trivial if you are the bat. Nor is the protection of species and habitats generally a trivial matter. Nor is compliance with EU law.

He said, “The fact that all parties in the present proceedings, and particularly the developer’s professional and ecological advisers, have concerned themselves so assiduously with the outcome for our bat and its roost shows that, despite everything, as far as the state of civilization in this country is concerned, all is not yet completely lost”.

Mr Justice Humphreys stated the company’s oral submissions utterly demolishes the objectors’ case in just six words, “the potentiality necessarily includes the actuality”.

CEO of Art Data Centres Ltd, Tom McNamara said on Sunday, “I welcome the court’s decision, it is fundamentally founded in common sense and reason”.

The project will create between 400- 450 permanent jobs when the data centre campus is fully operational with up to 1,200 jobs in construction.

Mr Justice Humphreys has listed the case for next Monday, March 31st to deal with matters arising from his judgement.

In his ruling, Mr Justice Humphreys commented whether, and to what extent, those opposed to the data centre “can make headway on the derogation licence issue or any other issue is for another day and for other parties to join in considering”.

Related News

c8722ce4-f474-408b-abc7-5f17194ea745
Ennis Skin and Makeup Studio is the first to win an online presence award
willie clancy week 8
Willie Clancy week records biggest & busiest run in Miltown Malbay
clare gaa convention 12-12-19 48 pat o'brien
Cultural change & lack of young customers a big factor in closure of rural Clare pubs - O'Brien
jamaica inn 1
Teenage witness didn't see Gilligan hit boy but heard sound of wood smacking off him

Advertisement

Latest News
c8722ce4-f474-408b-abc7-5f17194ea745
Ennis Skin and Makeup Studio is the first to win an online presence award
willie clancy week 8
Willie Clancy week records biggest & busiest run in Miltown Malbay
naomh eoin v clondegad 12-10-24 mossy gavin odhran lynch 1
Intermediate teams profiled as championship commences as highly competitive bid to lift Talty Cup takes off
lissycasey v ennistymon 22-03-25 darren keane 1
Lissycasey can liven up senior campaign with big breakthrough
wolfe tones v doonbeg 17-05-25 dean devanney 2
Wolfe Tones ready to jump for senior stepping stone
Premium
naomh eoin v clondegad 12-10-24 mossy gavin odhran lynch 1
Intermediate teams profiled as championship commences as highly competitive bid to lift Talty Cup takes off
lissycasey v ennistymon 22-03-25 darren keane 1
Lissycasey can liven up senior campaign with big breakthrough
wolfe tones v doonbeg 17-05-25 dean devanney 2
Wolfe Tones ready to jump for senior stepping stone
ennistymon v corofin 07-03-25 eoin rouine 1
Emotional encounter awaits Ennistymon as they bid to bring burning desire to the fold
clare gaa convention 12-12-19 48 pat o'brien
Cultural change & lack of young customers a big factor in closure of rural Clare pubs - O'Brien

Subscribe for just €3 per month

If you’re here, you care about County Clare. So do we. Did you rely on us for Covid-19 updates, follow our election coverage, or visit The Clare Echo every week for breaking news and sport? The Clare Echo invests in local journalism and we want to safeguard its future in our county. By becoming a subscriber you are supporting what we do, will receive access to all our premium articles and a better experience, while helping us improve our offering to you. Subscribe to clareecho.ie and get the first six months for just €3 a month (less than 75c per week), and thereafter €8 per month. Cancel anytime, limited time offer. T&Cs Apply. www.clareecho.ie.

Subscribe for just €3 per month

If you’re here, you care about County Clare. So do we. Did you rely on us for Covid-19 updates, follow our election coverage, or visit The Clare Echo every week for breaking news and sport? The Clare Echo invests in local journalism and we want to safeguard its future in our county. By becoming a subscriber you are supporting what we do, will receive access to all our premium articles and a better experience, while helping us improve our offering to you. Subscribe to clareecho.ie and get the first six months for just €3 a month (less than 75c per week), and thereafter €8 per month. Cancel anytime, limited time offer. T&Cs Apply. www.clareecho.ie.